Risk Management · 2024
In this section3 topics
Risk Management Policy & Plan
Policy & Plan Description
The company recognizes the importance of effective organizational administration to drive stable growth and business expansion, maintain a secure financial position, and provide proper yield to shareholders. Attention is given to addressing risks and fostering sustainable development in environmental, social, and corporate governance. The company has established policies and procedures for risk management to serve as a framework for best practices. This is intended to ensure that the risk management process is effective and adheres to high standards, in accordance with guidelines of good corporate governance.
Risk management framework
Risk management is an integral component of good corporate governance. In addition to supporting the Company in achieving its predefined goals, it also enables value enhancement for the Company’s stakeholders.
In 2024, the Company formed the Sustainability, Governance, and Risk Management Committee consisting of 9 members. Ms. Saifon Chaimongkol is the Chairman of the Sustainability, Governance, and Risk Management Committee and is responsible for strategy formulation and assigning oversight tasks to ensure that operations comply with good corporate governance principle, are transparent and fair to all relevant units, and align with the prescribed risk management guidelines. The company mandates regular risk assessment and management. In 2024, the committee held a total of 6 meetings and presented to the Company's Board of Directors once.
Additionally, the Company has hired Dharmniti Internal Audit Co., Ltd. to conduct internal assessments. Ms. Wantanee Wongbudrod holds the position of Deputy Manager of Internal Audit 2 and serves as the Head of Internal Audit. Ms. Somruethai Hemthanon acts as the Company's representative in coordinating internal audit activities across all hospitals in the chain.
Risks to the Company's Business Operations
Risk Register
| Risk Name | Risk Characteristics | Consequences | Management Measures | Related Risk Factors |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Business risks | Strategic and Business Risk Government Healthcare Policy Risk In 2024, the Group's revenue from services under the government's health policy, from services provided under the Social Security scheme, is estimated to be 33.16% of hospital revenue. Therefore, changes in the government's health policy could impact the Group's operating results. However, the Company's management has been monitoring changes and participating in providing input on various policy formulations to provide useful information to the committees considering the government's health policies. The Company's executives have participated as members of various committees, such as the Social Security Medical Committee, the National Health Service System Committee, advisors to the Labor Committee, and the Road Accident Victim Protection Committee, Department of Insurance, Ministry of Commerce. Additionally, the Company has a policy to control expenses and continuously evaluate the performance of such projects to mitigate the impact on the Company's overall operating results. Competitive Risk in the Private Hospital Business Competition in the private hospital business has intensified and returned to normal service provision. This includes competition in tertiary care services, service technologies, and specialized medical centers based on the expertise and specialization of each hospital network to retain existing patient bases and attract new patient groups to use hospital services. Management and Operational Risk Risk of Personnel Shortage As the healthcare service business relies on personnel with knowledge, skills, and specialized expertise in various fields, including medicine, pharmacy, nursing, and technical staff, the shortage of qualified personnel is one of the risks of the business. Risk of Fraud and Corruption The Company operates a private hospital business, which involves various sectors, such as the National Health Security Office, regarding reimbursement under the health promotion contract, the Social Security Office, regarding annual enrollment or renewal for medical services for insured persons, hospital accreditation institutions, and the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment, regarding the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) approval for new hospital openings or capacity expansions. Therefore, the Company may face the risk of employee fraud, both from individuals within and outside the company.
The Company's business operations involve the collection and use of confidential and personally identifiable information, including patient data, business partners, and employees within the Company and its network of hospitals. This poses a risk of privacy violations from internal operations, such as unauthorized access to information by employees, inaccurate data recording, and misuse of information. Regulatory and Legal Risk Risk of Litigation As the public is currently more informed and aware of their rights, including the issuance of several new laws that provide rights protection and benefits to consumers, such as the Consumer Case Procedure Act B.E. 2551, the Consumer Organization Council Establishment Act B.E. 2562, and the Personal Data Protection Act B.E. 2562. These laws will facilitate consumers in taking legal action against hospitals and medical personnel, increasing the company's risk of litigation arising from the provision of healthcare services. Social and Community Risks The Company operates a total of 15 hospitals located in communities both domestically and internationally. This makes the hospitals connected to the local communities. The Company strives to collaborate with and support agencies and organizations that play a role in social assistance, such as providing health check-up units to people residing near the hospitals. In addition, the Company prioritizes the health and safety of patients, communities, and stakeholders at all levels. Moreover, the Company is mindful of the risks arising from the disposal of infectious waste and other types of waste. It has established an Environment of Care Committee (ECC) to ensure the effectiveness of environmental and safety operations. The ECC is responsible for assessing issues that impact the environment and safety of hospital staff, service users, and the surrounding community. It also develops risk management programs for potential environmental impacts from the hospital's business operations. Furthermore, the Company respects human rights by establishing a human rights policy based on the three pillars of the United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights: Protect, Respect, and Remedy. The Company also conducts a comprehensive Human Rights Due Diligence Process. Financial Risk Credit Risk As the hospitals in the network provide healthcare services to various patient groups, covering both cash patients who pay for their own expenses or utilize benefits from contracted companies or insurance companies, and patients under the Social Security scheme, the Company needs to collect fees from private companies, insurance companies, and government agencies. Liquidity Risk The Company manages liquidity risk by maintaining a level of cash and cash equivalents sufficient to meet the operating needs of the Company and its subsidiaries, including considering the need for appropriate funding in line with future business expansion or investment plans. Interest Rate Risk Interest rate risk arises from future changes in market interest rates, which affect the Company's operating results and cash flow. However, the Company has set an appropriate proportion of loans and borrowings of the Company and its subsidiaries with fixed and floating interest rates. It also monitors and manages risk by sourcing funds with appropriate financing costs, preparing financial projections, and estimating and analyzing future financial ratios to ensure that key financial ratios are at appropriate levels. Foreign Exchange Risk As the Company operates a network of hospitals in Lao PDR, with revenue and loan financing in Lao Kip, there may be a risk of foreign exchange fluctuations due to economic conditions. The Company has measures in place to manage foreign currency income and expenses accordingly (Natural Hedge) to mitigate this risk appropriately. | Strategic and Business Risk Risk from Government Healthcare Policies As approximately 33.16% of the company's revenue comes from government projects such as Social Security and the National Health Security Office, if there are policy changes, such as a reduction in service rates or service conditions, it may directly impact the company's revenue. Competitive Risk in the Private Hospital Business Competition in the business compels the company to develop medical technology and expand specialized service centers to meet patient needs. This includes improving the surrounding environment of the hospital and increasing medical personnel and related staff. Management and Operational Risk Risk of Personnel Shortage The shortage of qualified personnel is one of the business risks. As the healthcare service business relies on personnel with knowledge, skills, and expertise in specific fields, including medical, pharmaceutical, nursing, and various technical staff, and with the current high competition in the hospital business, both in the public and private sectors, inaction by the company could affect business operations. Corruption Risk If the company does not conduct business transparently, it may cause damage to the company's reputation and image, loss of trust in the company, which will affect business relationships and future operations, including impacting financial performance and all stakeholders involved with the company. It can also lead to the loss of opportunities to collaborate with new business partners or expand into new markets due to mistrust arising from corrupt practices. Risk of Personal Data Breach Data access by unauthorized employees, incorrect data recording, and misuse of information will affect patients' confidence in using the service, as well as the company's reputation and image, which may have a negative impact in the industry. This could have a significant impact on the company's operations, financial position, and cash flow. Regulatory and Legal Risk Risk of Litigation The company places importance on reporting and negotiating solutions when there are complaints from service users. This is to prevent or mitigate legal disputes. The company collects litigation cases to present to the Sustainability, Governance, and Risk Management Committee and the Board of Directors to adjust management strategies and continuously improve service quality. Currently, the company has litigation cases filed by patients claiming damages with a total claim amount of approximately 398 million baht as of December 31, 2024. Details of the progress are disclosed in Note 28 to the Financial Statements. As of the date of this report, these cases are still under court proceedings, and the outcome of these cases is not yet finalized. Based on management's assessment, there is no expected material adverse effect. Therefore, the Group has not recognized any provision for liabilities in the financial statements. Financial Risk Credit Risk The company provides healthcare services covering cash patients who pay for themselves, use their rights from contracted companies or insurance companies, and patients under the Social Security scheme. This requires the company to collect expenses from private companies, insurance companies, and government agencies. Therefore, there is a risk of uncollectible medical expenses if there is no analysis, management, and follow-up on payments from contractors. | Strategic and Business Risk Risk from Government Healthcare Policies The company has implemented risk mitigation measures by closely monitoring government policies and participating as an advisory committee in several relevant agencies. Competition Risk in the Private Hospital Business The Company has been dedicated to continuously improving the potentiality and standards of hospitals within the group through the enhancement of service areas and patient accommodation facilities in hospitals such as Kasemrad Bangkae Hospital, Kasemrad Prachachuen Hospital, Kasemrad Saraburi Hospital, and Kasemrad Chachoengsao Hospital. Additionally, Karunvej Pathumthani Hospital has been upgraded to Kasemrad Pathumthani Hospital. Moreover, the Company has fostered collaborations with various organizations to expand the customer base into new markets. These include partnership between World Medical Hospital and SENERA Senior Wellness Co., Ltd. to manage the medical aspects of the Senera Senior Wellness project at Bang Bua Thong branch, catering to the aging society in Thailand. The Company has also collaborated with Lavida Advanced Fertility and Genetics Center Co., Ltd. to elevate the quality of healthcare and expand the patient base to the People's Republic of China. Additionally, there are partnerships with experts catering to customers in the beauty industry with the establishment of the Kasemrad Plastic Surgery centers within two hospitals in the group which has yielded positive results. The mobile dental services provided by Bangkok Chain Dental Co., Ltd. have been launched in six provinces and have received positive feedback. These services cater to government agencies, private companies, public schools, and private schools. Furthermore, the Company has introduced specialized medical centers within hospitals in the group to enhance services and improve competitiveness. Ongoing studies are being conducted to explore strategic areas for potential expansion of hospital operations in the future, aiming to broaden services to cover a larger customer base. Management and Operational Risk Risk of Personnel Shortage To mitigate the risk of personnel shortage, the group has set competitive compensation rates and appropriate benefits that can compete with other operators. It also provides opportunities for qualified personnel to participate in management and provides continuous training to enhance new knowledge. This is to encourage such personnel to feel involved in the company's business growth. Risk of Fraud and Corruption The company recognizes the potential for fraud and has established concrete guidelines for various matters. An anti-corruption policy has been developed to demonstrate the company's commitment to combating corruption, along with an anti-corruption practice manual to clearly define roles, responsibilities, principles, and regulations. Communication and training are provided to the board of directors, management, and employees of the company and its subsidiaries, as well as agents, business intermediaries, product/service distributors, contractors, or consultants who are involved with or act on behalf of the company and/or its subsidiaries. Risk of Personal Data Breach The company places importance on personal data protection. It has established a privacy policy announcement, obtained consent for data collection and usage, established data security measures, and provided channels for employees and stakeholders to file complaints. It has also appointed a Data Protection Officer (DPO) to oversee all personal data within the company, provide advice, audit, and supervise the use of personal data in accordance with the Personal Data Protection Act B.E. 2562 (PDPA). The company also prioritizes the protection of the rights of customers/patients and stakeholders to ensure they are treated fairly and in accordance with relevant privacy laws. Regulatory and Legal Risk Litigation Risk The company is aware of these risk factors and has implemented risk management measures. These include processes for monitoring, inspecting, and controlling the quality and standards of medical treatment, as well as evaluating service satisfaction. The company also continuously enhances service standards in accordance with Hospital Accreditation (HA) and Joint Commission International (JCI) standards. Financial Risk Credit Risk The company has a policy to mitigate such risks by communicating treatment plans, along with an assessment of the costs incurred, and informing patients of the costs in advance. It also offers payment installment options to alleviate the burden of paying for medical treatment in full upon completion of treatment. The creditworthiness of each new counterparty is analyzed before offering terms and conditions of trade. In addition, the company has in place management and monitoring of receivables from counterparties, insurance companies, and government agencies to ensure that medical treatment payments are made according to the agreed terms. Liquidity Risk The company manages liquidity risk by maintaining a level of cash and cash equivalents sufficient for the operating needs of the company and its subsidiaries. It also considers the need for appropriate financing in line with future expansion or investment plans. Interest Rate Risk The company has set appropriate proportions of loans and borrowings of the company and its subsidiaries with fixed and floating interest rates. It also monitors and manages risk by sourcing funds at reasonable financing costs, preparing financial projections, and estimating and analyzing various financial ratios that will occur in the future to ensure that key financial ratios are at appropriate levels. Foreign Exchange Risk The company has measures in place to manage income and expenses in foreign currencies accordingly (Natural Hedge) to appropriately manage such risks. | 738 · Description: Reliance on employees in key positions · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 756 · Description: Change in laws and regulations · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK · 739 · Description: Shortage or reliance on skilled workers · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 757 · Description: Laws and regulations is not favorable for doing business · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK · 730 · Description: Government policy · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK · 758 · Description: Violations of laws and regulations · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK · 764 · Description: Fluctuation in exchange rates, interest rates, or the inflation rate · Info category: FINANCIAL_RISK · 742 · Description: Human error in business operations · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 1724 · Description: Liquidity risk · Info category: FINANCIAL_RISK · 736 · Description: Damage to company image and reputation · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK · 1714 · Description: Competition risk · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK · 1718 · Description: Pandemic risk · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK · 754 · Description: Corruption · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 1722 · Description: Pandemic risk · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| Emerging risks | Emerging Risks Information Technology System Change Risk The advancement of information technology systems today enhances opportunities for development and elevates service delivery for various businesses, including hospitals, ultimately improving people's quality of life. Misinformation and Disinformation in Healthcare Communication of information today is fast and easy, primarily occurring through online media channels that are not always verified or filtered by relevant authorities. This has led to distortions in public health information, which may negatively impact people's understanding of healthcare and treatment. The rapid spread of diseases on a large scale can cause panic, lead to stockpiling of goods, and undermine public confidence in the healthcare system. Risks Arising from Emerging Diseases The changing global climate, including global warming, floods, droughts, wildfires, heat waves, and various dust and smoke, inevitably impacts the lives and health of people and living beings worldwide. It can also be a factor leading to emerging diseases from changes in lifestyle and health behaviors. Climate Change Risk Climate change may lead to disasters and scarcity of natural resources in many areas, with increasing severity. | Emerging risks Information technology system change risk The advancement of information technology systems also poses a risk of cybersecurity threats, such as attempted data breaches by outsiders, data theft, or data destruction to disrupt services. This will affect the confidence, reputation, and image of the company and may have a significant impact on the company's operating results, financial position, and cash flows. Misinformation and Disinformation in Healthcare False or inaccurate public health communication can lead to panic through misunderstanding or the spreading of misinformation. For example, sharing fake news that certain herbs can cure diseases without scientific evidence, or rumors that vaccines cause severe side effects without proof. This can result in patients avoiding proper treatment, potentially increasing the risk of death or complications. It can also lead to the neglect of appropriate preventive measures, causing faster disease outbreaks. Additionally, it creates societal panic, leading to hoarding of essential goods and negatively affecting the economy and daily life.
The risks from global climate change may positively impact and generate revenue for the company and its network of hospitals. However, at the same time, it may negatively impact hospital management in the event of serious health risks that result in more patients needing care than the company's public health service system can support. Climate change risk Climate change affects the quality of life and is a risk that could result in the company being unable to conduct business normally. | Emerging risks Risk of changes in information technology systems The Company manages risk by continuously studying and upgrading its technology security systems to prevent cyber threats to the Company's information technology systems, as well as raising awareness of safe technology use among the Company's personnel. Misinformation and Disinformation in Healthcare The company campaigns to educate the public and promote health literacy to ensure accurate information is received. It also controls and supervises the information shared on online media and encourages the involvement of experts to provide scientifically-based information through reliable channels, such as news sources from health organizations or government agencies. This is done to prevent the spread of misinformation and reduce its impact on public health.4o mini Risk of emerging diseases The Company has a risk management approach based on experience and expertise from managing the COVID-19 pandemic, such as having a network of hotels that can be adapted to serve as field hospitals in the event of an outbreak of emerging diseases. The Company has experience in providing telemedicine services, as well as preparing to adopt new technologies to provide medical services for patients' convenience.
The Company places importance on natural resource conservation and reducing direct and indirect environmental impacts. The Company also conducts business by considering the impacts on the environment, communities, employees, partners, and all stakeholders. | 732 · Description: Changes in technologies · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK · 750 · Description: Climate change and disasters · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 737 · Other name: Misinformation in communication · Description: Other · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK |
Risks to Securities Holders' Investment
Risk Register
| Risk Name | Risk Characteristics | Consequences | Management Measures | Related Risk Factors |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shareholder Investment Risk | As market demand and supply are constantly changing, often due to multiple factors, the price of securities is not solely dependent on the company's performance. | This risk may cause investors to lose all or part of their investment. To mitigate this potential risk, investors can diversify their investments across multiple industries to spread the risk. | The company has implemented measures to manage such risks by adhering to good corporate governance principles and sustainable business practices to ensure fairness for all shareholders equally. | 768 · Description: Return from investment of securities holder · Info category: HOLDER_RISK |

